Independent advice. We don't sell cars or loans. · Dom works in the car business
1-on-1 calls by appointmentFree ToolsContact

Trade-in sanity check: compare your written offers

Got two or three written trade-in offers? Type them in. You'll see which is highest, how far apart they are, and whether one looks like an outlier — compared only to your other offers, never to a book value. Optional: your payoff and what you paid, for equity and retained-share math from those numbers alone. Public market indexes (BLS and Manheim) sit below as context. Not an appraisal. Nothing you type leaves this page.

1. Your written offers

Type 2 or 3 offers you already have in writing. Cap is 3. Amounts over $500,000 or negative are ignored.

Offer 1

Required for a comparison.
Label only. No brand picker.

Offer 2

Required for a comparison.
Label only. No brand picker.

Offer 3 (optional)

Leave blank if you only have two.
Label only. No brand picker.
Optional context (payoff, what you paid, miles, year)
From your lender. Used only for equity = offer - payoff.
Your number only. Used for a retained % from the numbers you typed, not a market residual.
Number only. No make or model asked.

How this works

Every dollar amount is one you typed. We rank your offers, show the median and mean, the dollar and percent spread ((high - low) ÷ high), and flag any offer 10% or more below your highest or 10% or more above the next. Equity and retained share use only your payoff and what-you-paid figures. The BLS and Manheim panels are national market indexes embedded at build time — not a value for your car. We never quote Kelley Blue Book, Edmunds or CARFAX book values.

2. Your comparison

Type at least 2 offers above and the ranking shows here.

Public market context (not a valuation)

These are market-level indexes, not an appraisal of your car. We never quote Kelley Blue Book, Edmunds or CARFAX values for your vehicle. Not an appraisal. Not a buy/sell offer. Educational only.

BLS CPI-U Used Cars and Trucks

Seasonally adjusted · series CUSR0000SETA02

  • Sep 2026: 182.176
  • Aug 2026: 180.965
  • Sep 2025: 184.869
  • Month over month (Aug→Sep 2026): +0.7%
  • Year over year (Sep 2025→Sep 2026): -1.5%

Source: BLS via FRED (CUSR0000SETA02). Checked Nov 4, 2026. Next BLS release about Nov 10, 2026 for October.

Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index

Wholesale · mix / mileage / seasonality adjusted · mid-October 2026 (first 15 days)

  • Index: 207.4
  • vs September: +0.7%
  • Year over year: +2.2%
  • Wholesale days' supply: 28.2

Source: Cox Automotive Insights, published Oct 19, 2026. Preliminary mid-month; full October index due Nov 6, 2026.

Your trade offer is a number between dealers, not an index reading. Compare written offers; then settle the selling price separately on an itemized buyer's order.

Educational only, not an appraisal. General education, not legal or financial advice. Confirm every number on the dealer's itemized buyer's order before you sign.

What this calculator doesn't tell you

The math above is complete for the numbers you typed. It can't see the dealer's quote. These need the paid tools:

  • Whether the trade-in and payoff are shown correctly on the buyer's order Deal Assessment
  • Whether negative equity is hidden in the price or amount financed Deal Assessment
  • Whether the doc fee and add-ons are fair Deal Assessment
  • A line-by-line Deal Assessment of the actual quote Deal Assessment
  • Answers to new questions as they come up while you shop, and recall lookups by VIN AI Desk

Start here

Got a dealer quote? Get a Deal Assessment.

That's your estimate from the numbers you typed. Have the dealer's written quote? Your Deal Assessment checks the tax, fees, APR and add-ons line by line and gives you the words to use. $69, one time.

Assess my quote · $69

Shopping for weeks? AI Desk, $89/month includes 2 Deal Assessments a month and questions answered any time (fair use: 30 a day). Renews monthly until you cancel. Cancel anytime.

Independent advice. We don't sell cars or loans. Dom works in the car business; we take no commissions from dealers, lenders or automakers. General education only, not financial or legal advice.

Questions

What is this tool?

A free comparison of the written trade-in offers you already have. It ranks them, shows the dollar and percent spread, flags offers 10% or more off your highest or next, and (if you type a payoff or what you paid) shows equity and retained share from those numbers. It is not an appraisal and not a buy or sell offer.

Is this an appraisal of my car?

No. We never invent a market value for your specific car, and we never quote Kelley Blue Book, Edmunds or CARFAX values for your vehicle. The only dollar amounts are the ones you type. The BLS and Manheim figures are market-level indexes, not an appraisal of your car.

Why compare multiple written offers?

One offer is a number; two or three written offers show the range. A dealer is more likely to match or beat a higher written offer when you can show it. Get each offer on an itemized buyer's order with the trade allowance separate from the selling price.

What do the BLS and Manheim indexes mean?

The BLS CPI-U Used Cars and Trucks series is a national retail price index for used vehicles. The Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index is a wholesale (auction) index adjusted for mix, mileage and seasonality. Both move for the whole market. Neither one is a value for your car, your mileage or your condition.

Does it save or send what I type?

No. It runs entirely in your browser. Nothing you type is sent to us or stored, and there's no share link. You copy the dealer note yourself; nobody from Ask Dom contacts the dealer.